Chasing The Unicorn

Your Quest For the Perfect Pour
The seal of The Wantage — a wantage rod standing in the bung of a barrel

Issue

The Wantage

Week of 27–31 July 2026

The gap between what the barrel claims and what is in it.

← The Wantage  /  Week of 27–31 July 2026

01

The Question

one question, argued

Is the scarcity story still worth what producers are charging for it?

02

The Verdict

The positionNo. Distillers are raising allocated prices and dressing up scarcity harder than ever, but the people who actually buy that scarcity — collectors on the resale market — have been paying less for it every month since May. When the buyers stop believing the story before the sellers do, the sellers are wrong.

-4.7 pts
The same tracked bottles that commanded a 41.3% premium over MSRP on secondary in June are only fetching 36.6% over MSRP in July — the steepest monthly drop since tracking began in April.
03

The Evidence

8 points · 2026-05-13 to 2026-07-28

Assembled from the daily brief’s own archive across months — the part no single day’s news can show. Every line is dated so it can be checked.

2026-05-13Buffalo Trace raised George T. Stagg's list price$129.99 to $149.99, +15.4%
2026-06-07Kentucky distillers reported a year-over-year drop in how much bourbon they actually made-12.7% YoY proof-gallons
2026-06-13Matched-basket secondary floor (same bottles tracked month to month) started sliding42.5% to 41.6% premium over MSRP, May to June
2026-07-15Pappy Van Winkle 15-Year's resale average droppeddown 8% to ~$780
2026-07-18A 2019 Elijah Craig 18-Year sold on secondary for less than half what it fetched three years ago$210, down from $475 in 2023
2026-07-22Heaven Hill told distributors to expect another wholesale price hike on Elijah Craig and Larceny6-8% effective Aug 1
2026-07-28Peerless put its rickhouse floor number directly on a federal label for the first time — a provenance flourish aimed straight at the scarcity buyerfirst-ever disclosure
2026-07-28Bardstown Bourbon Co. released a rum-cask finish capped under 350 cases at nearly $140 a bottle, betting scarcity alone sells it<350 cases, $139.99
04

So What

by where you sit

The same week means different things to a distiller, a retailer and a collector.

If you buy for retailStop paying above MSRP on allocated cases betting on a flip — the premium buyers were flipping into has shrunk 4.7 points in a single month.
If you work in brandDon't greenlight another sub-350-case superpremium finish assuming rarity alone justifies the price; the last three months of resale data say collectors are already saying no to that math.
If you run production/capacityKeep the cuts you've already made — the 12.7% output decline is the industry agreeing with what the resale floor is telling you, not overreacting to it.
If you're evaluating an investment or acquisitionRead Brown-Forman's second rejection of Sazerac's $15 billion bid against its own 12% workforce cut and cooperage closure — a board betting its brand is worth more than a buyer will pay, while trimming costs like one that isn't sure.
05

The Call

dated and falsifiable

Three predictions with dates on them, published so they can be wrong.

By 30 Sep 2026The next matched-basket secondary reading will show a fourth straight monthly decline, pushing the average premium below 35%.

By 31 Dec 2026At least one major producer (Heaven Hill, Buffalo Trace, or Wild Turkey) will roll back or quietly discount an MSRP increase made earlier in 2026 on a barrel-proof or allocated SKU.

By 31 Dec 2026Brown-Forman will name a new CEO before it accepts, or further rejects, any acquisition offer.

Calls are never edited after publication. When one misses it is marked in corrections and stays on this page.

06

What I’m Watching

the publisher’s own read

What I'm watching is that matched-basket secondary number in August and September. We've had three straight months of decline now — May up 4.1, June down 1.0, July down 4.7 — and if that reading falls again, that's not a wobble, that's collectors telling every distiller in Kentucky they're done paying up for the story. I'd also keep an eye on whether a 2026 BTAC bottle trades at or under its own MSRP; Eagle Rare 17 and Elijah Craig 18 are already most of the way there. If either happens, the scarcity premium isn't just softening. It's gone.

— John Schuster II, publisher, the American Whiskey Industry Brief

How this is built

The Wantage takes one question the trade is actually arguing about and answers it with evidence assembled across months, not a recap of the week. Every figure comes from the American Whiskey Industry Brief’s own daily record, and the monthly measurements behind it are published in The Gauge. Where the archive disagrees with itself, the figure is withheld rather than asserted.

Open this issue (PDF) →

Cite as: The Wantage, Vol. 1 No. 1 (Week of 27–31 July 2026), Drunken Unicorn Productions.

The archive

July 20261 issue

This is the first issue.

Every issue of The Wantage, and this week’s →